Former Miss Bay Area Teen
| 2010 Raigan Harris |
2009 Jessica Mitchell |
2008 Megan Scamardo |
2007 Jessica Kirkland |
2006 Lauren Adkins |
| 2005 Michelle Bergeson |
2004 Taylor Lanning |
2003 Sarah Ford |
2002 Poushali Bhattacharjee |
2001 Lauren Lanning |
| 2000 Lauren James |
1999 Nicole O'Brian |
1998 Holly White |
1997 Sarah Donnelly |